Special Offers for First Responders & Frontline Personnel

Let’s create your haven for relaxing and recharging.

We’ve got you!

The “Hearth” of the Matter: Choosing Between Gas, Wood and Pellet Fireplace Inserts

The “Hearth” of the Matter: Choosing Between Gas, Wood and Pellet Fireplace Inserts

As the premier fireplace store in Kansas City, Complete Home Concepts is the perfect resource for deciding between gas, wood or pellet fireplace inserts. We’ve walked countless KC homeowners through the decision process to ensure they’re happy with their choice. The good news is that all three types of fireplace inserts deliver reliable heat come winter and a variety of styles to match every type of home. The bad news is that all three have substantial benefits, so the decision can end up being a six of one, half a dozen of the other type.

Is a Gas Fireplace Insert Right for You?

Gas fireplace inserts are a popular choice thanks to their convenience and efficiency. They provide a substantial amount of heat output with just a flick of a switch, and many of today’s models come with remote controls and control via phone app. With a gas fireplace insert from our fireplace store in Kansas City, you won’t have to worry about buying, chopping or storing wood, making them an easy addition to your living space.

Three key benefits of gas fireplace inserts are:

  1. Easy and efficient: Gas fireplace inserts are all about convenience. They’re highly efficient, converting most of the gas to heat, which means lower heating bills for you.
  2. Environmentally friendly: Gas burns cleaner than wood, releasing fewer pollutants into the atmosphere. Modern units come with sealed combustion units that reduce drafts and increase efficiency.
  3. Design options: From traditional log sets to contemporary glass beads or stones, gas inserts offer design versatility. With customizable options, you can match your insert to your decor, creating a focal point that is as stylish as it is functional and efficient.

However, gas fireplace inserts are not without drawbacks. If your home doesn’t already have a gas line, the cost of installation will be higher. Also, while the flames in a gas fireplace are gorgeous, they may not suffice for traditionalists who want the classic, cozy ambiance of a wood-burning fireplace.

Would a Wood Fireplace Insert be a Better Fit for You?

When it comes to traditional appeal and the timeless allure of a crackling fire, nothing can replace a wood fireplace insert. They are excellent for heat generation and create an unmatched, cozy atmosphere. Wood is a renewable resource, and if you already have a steady, easy source for wood, it can be cost-effective.

Three key considerations for wood fireplace inserts are:

  1. Timeless appeal: There’s something incredibly comforting about the crackle of a wood fire. It’s a sensory experience – the smell of burning wood and the sound of crackling logs. Simply timeless.
  2. Fuel availability: Kansas City has abundant wood available, either for sale or if you or someone you know owns wooded land, so a wood fireplace insert can be a cost-effective solution. However, storage can be an issue. Consider whether you have the space to store firewood far enough away from your home, so as not to attract bugs or other pests who enjoy nesting in wood piles.
  3. Environment: Modern wood inserts are more efficient than their open-hearth counterparts and meet EPA’s clean-air standards. Even still, they release more particulates into the atmosphere than gas or pellet inserts. If you’re not a heavy wood fireplace insert user, then this might not be a deciding factor.

On the flip side, wood fireplace inserts require more maintenance than gas or pellet inserts. You’ll need to clean the ash and soot regularly and have the chimney swept to prevent creosote buildup.

Have You Checked Out Pellet Fireplace Inserts?

Pellet fireplace inserts are an eco-friendly alternative that has gained popularity in recent years. Pellets are made from compressed sawdust and other byproducts, making them a fantastic choice for the environmentally conscious homeowner. They are also highly efficient and easy to use, with some models offering automatic feeding systems.

Some advantages of pellet fireplace inserts are:

  1. Efficiency: Pellet inserts have extremely high efficiency, often above 80%. This means lower heating costs and a cozy, warm home.
  2. Environmentally friendly: Pellets are made from waste wood, like sawdust and wood shavings, making them a renewable and sustainable fuel source. They also burn cleaner than logs, producing less air pollution.
  3. Ease of use: With automatic feeding systems and thermostatic controls, pellet stoves offer a high level of convenience.

The downside of pellet fireplace inserts is they require electricity to operate. This dependency means that in the event of a power outage, you could be left in the cold. Also, pellets may not be as readily available as gas or wood, and the cost of pellets can fluctuate.

Other Factors to Consider When Choosing the Right Fireplace Insert

When it comes to choosing between gas, wood, or pellet fireplace inserts, consider:

  • Your lifestyle and convenience. If you want a low-maintenance option, a gas fireplace might be right for you. But if you’re drawn to the charm of a real wood fire and don’t mind a bit of cleaning, consider a wood insert.
  • The availability and cost of fuel in your area. Gas is generally available in most regions, but if you live in a wooded area or have land, you may have an ample supply of firewood. If you’re committed to using renewable energy, consider a pellet fireplace insert.
  • The aesthetic you want. Each type of insert provides a different look and feel, from the modern allure of gas to the traditional charm of wood and the eco-friendly aspect of pellets.

Choosing the right fireplace insert isn’t merely about the type of fuel. Consider installation and running costs, fuel availability, maintenance needs and environmental impact. But most importantly, think about how each type would fit into your lifestyle and home aesthetics.

Want to see them in person and discuss your needs with an expert? Complete Home Concepts Kansas City has a wide variety of fireplace inserts to suit every style and need. Visit our showroom or contact us to discuss your options with our experienced team.